If you click on the links and make a purchase, we may earn a commission.
Image Credit: Havells
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
Choosing the right room heater can make a big difference in comfort, electricity bills, and safety during winter. Among all heater types, oil filled heaters and fan heaters are the most commonly used in Indian households. But which one is better for your needs?
In this detailed guide, we compare Oil Filled Heater vs Fan Heater based on heating performance, energy efficiency, safety, noise level, and suitability for Indian homes.
What Is an Oil Filled Heater?
An oil filled heater uses thermic oil sealed inside metal fins. When electricity heats the oil, the heater radiates warmth slowly and evenly into the room.
Key Characteristics:
- No fan or blower
- Silent operation
- Long heat retention
- Suitable for extended usage
Oil filled heaters are popular for bedrooms, living rooms, and overnight heating.
What Is a Fan Heater?
A fan heater uses an electric heating element combined with a blower fan to push hot air into the room.
Key Characteristics:
- Instant heat
- Compact and portable
- Uses a fan motor
- Suitable for short-term heating
Fan heaters are commonly used for quick warmth in small spaces.
Heating Performance Comparison
Oil Filled Heater
- Takes longer to warm the room
- Maintains temperature for a long time
- Provides uniform heating
Fan Heater
- Heats the room quickly
- Temperature drops immediately when switched off
- Uneven heat distribution
Winner: Oil Filled Heater (for comfort)
- Power Full Heating: 9-Fin 2400W (800 W / 1200 W / 2000 W + 400W PTC) with PTC Fan heater of 400W.
- Superior grade oil for long-lasting heat and better efficiency. Superior thermooxidative stability minimizes sludge & va…
- Superior safety with IS 302-2-30. Mark of safety ensuring appliance withstand the electric failures
Energy Efficiency Comparison
Oil Filled Heater
- Consumes power initially
- Retains heat even after switching off
- More efficient for long usage
Fan Heater
- Continuous high power consumption
- No heat retention
- Higher electricity bills for long use
Winner: Oil Filled Heater (for energy savings)
Noise Level Comparison
Oil Filled Heater
- Completely silent
- Ideal for sleeping and work
Fan Heater
- Noticeable fan noise
- Can be disturbing at night
Winner: Oil Filled Heater
Safety Comparison
Oil Filled Heater
- No exposed heating element
- Lower fire risk
- Safe for children and elderly
Fan Heater
- Hot air outlet
- Higher risk if placed near curtains or bedding
Winner: Oil Filled Heater
- Meant for Spot Heating
- Room Size: Upto 150 sq ft, Overheat Protection: Yes
- ISI Mark
Room Size Suitability
| Room Size | Oil Filled Heater | Fan Heater |
|---|---|---|
| Small room | Good | Very Good |
| Medium room | Excellent | Average |
| Large room | Very Good | Poor |
Usage Duration
Oil Filled Heater
- Best for 6–10 hours continuous use
- Safe for overnight heating
Fan Heater
- Best for 15–60 minutes use
- Not recommended for overnight use
Maintenance & Durability
Oil Filled Heater
- Minimal maintenance
- Long lifespan
- No moving parts
Fan Heater
- Fan motor can wear out
- Requires regular cleaning
Cost Comparison
Initial Cost
- Oil Filled Heater: Higher upfront cost
- Fan Heater: Cheaper and affordable
Long-Term Cost
- Oil Filled Heater: Lower electricity bills
- Fan Heater: Higher power consumption
Which One Is Better for Indian Homes?
Choose Oil Filled Heater If:
- You need silent heating
- You use heater for long hours
- You want energy efficiency
- You need safe overnight heating
Choose Fan Heater If:
- You need quick heat occasionally
- You have a small room
- You want a low-budget option
- You don’t mind some noise
Oil Filled Heater vs Fan Heater: Comparison Table
| Feature | Oil Filled Heater | Fan Heater |
|---|---|---|
| Heating speed | Moderate | Fast |
| Noise | Silent | Noisy |
| Energy efficiency | High | Low |
| Safety | Very High | Medium |
| Best for | Bedrooms, living rooms | Short-term heating |
| Overnight use | Yes | No |
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Using fan heaters overnight
- Blocking heater airflow
- Running heaters at max power continuously
- Using extension cords
Final Verdict: Oil Filled Heater vs Fan Heater
If comfort, safety, and energy efficiency matter, oil filled heaters are the clear winner. They are ideal for Indian winters, especially for bedrooms and long usage.
Fan heaters still have their place for quick, temporary heating, but they are not suitable for extended use.
Our recommendation:
- For home and family use → Oil Filled Heater
- For short-term or personal use → Fan Heater
👉 Related Articles on Wooloom.in:
India (🇮🇳)
USA (🇺🇸)